If it seems like MLB's collection of young shortstop talent recently went through a dry spell, you're not wrong. Between 2010 and 2013, the shortstop position was indeed lacking in young talent.
But one can look at what baseball has now and feel compelled to borrow a line from an upcoming science fiction film: There has been an awakening.
Throughout 2015, it seemed like a talented young shortstop was arriving every other week, seemingly resulting in a bumper crop of shortstop talent. And now that we're a few weeks removed from the end of the regular season, we can safely remove words like "seemed" and "seemingly" from this conversation.
In fact, FanGraphs WAR says it's no contest. Shortstops age 25 or younger produced more WAR in 2015 than they had in any other year in MLB history. And even since MLB expanded to 30 teams in 1998—thus creating more opportunities for young shortstops to find their way—it's not even close:
At one end of this spectrum, we're looking at Alex Rodriguez, Nomar Garciaparra and Derek Jeter lighting up the young shortstop leaderboards in 1998. At the other end, we're looking at a 2015 young shortstop class marked by both depth and a handful of budding superstars.
Among the latter, three 21-year-olds stand out: Carlos Correa, Francisco Lindor and Corey Seager.
In just 99 games for the Houston Astros, Correa posted an .857 OPS and led all MLB shortstops with 22 home runs. Lindor also played in 99 games, giving the Cleveland Indians a .313 average and arguably the best defense of any American League shortstop. Seager arrived much later but still opened eyes by hitting .337 with a .986 OPS in 27 games for the Los Angeles Dodgers.
More recently, two of these three have put their talents under the national spotlight in the postseason.
Though his Astros failed to advance past the American League Division Series, Correa definitely presented himself well in his first taste of the playoffs.
He hit .292 in six games, with the highlight being a four-hit, two-homer performance in Game 4 of the ALDS that nearly put the Astros in the ALCS. And though his key error was a turning point in that game, it should not be forgotten that he also made some good plays in Houston's six playoff games.
In so doing, Correa once again showed that, as Ben Reiter of Sports Illustrated put it, he's "an amalgamation of attributes that don't seem as if they ought to go together." He has all the power you'd expect from a player who goes 6'4" and 210 pounds, and he also has the athleticism to cut it as an above-average baserunner and defender.
As for Seager, his first taste of the postseason saw him collect only three hits and a walk in five games against the New York Mets' vaunted pitching staff.
But for what it's worth, Seager also made his presence felt on defense. And when what looked to be a mere foul pop fly darn near went over the fence in Game 1 of the NLDS, Seager showed off the natural hitting ability that landed him in the top spot of Baseball America's midseason prospect rankings.
As easy as it is to notice Correa's impossible combination of tools and Seager's sweet swing, though, you can take it from Lindor that they have other qualities that make them even more special.
Lindor said in a phone interview with Bleacher Report that he would have absolutely loved to play in the postseason alongside Correa and Seager. But in the meantime, he's been watching the action intently—he harbors no ill will against Chase Utley, for the record, as Lindor is "sure" he didn't mean to harm Ruben Tejada with his controversial slide in Game 2 of the NLDS—and among the things that have caught his attention is the demeanor of his fellow shortstops.
"When I watch Correa, I just see how he has so much confidence," Lindor said. "It looks like anything that's thrown to him, he's going to put a good swing on the ball. That's something that not a lot of players have."
And Seager?
"I think about how calm he is," Lindor explained. "How calm he is in the batter's box. How calm he is catching ground balls. How he doesn't let the game speed up on him. I think that's pretty unique. That's [also] something that not a lot of players have."
Sadly, Correa and Seager are out of the postseason now, as Seager's Dodgers followed Correa's Astros out the door with their loss to the Mets in Game 5 of the NLDS on Thursday night.
But lest anyone lament the sudden absence of two of baseball's best rookies, here's a reminder that there are plenty of good ones left standing.
Even without fellow rookie shortstop Addison Russell, who has been ruled out for the NLCS with an injury, the Chicago Cubs have slugging phenoms Kris Bryant and Kyle Schwarber. And in the likes of Noah Syndergaard, Marcus Stroman and Roberto Osuna, the Mets and Toronto Blue Jays have their share of hard-throwing right-handers who are just beginning to make names for themselves.
Besides which, October certainly hasn't seen the last of Correa and Seager. They're entrenched as cornerstones on two powerhouse teams and, as Lindor put it, "are going to be relied on for a very, very long time."
On that note, it takes one to know two. Because as exciting as Correa and Seager look, Lindor might actually be better than either of them.
Lindor may have been less heralded than Correa and Seager in 2015, but he deserved quite the opposite brand of treatment. For as good as they were, it was Lindor who became WAR's best friend.
According to FanGraphs WAR, Lindor was the best of baseball's young shortstops. According to Baseball-Reference.com WAR, he was only as good as Xander Bogaerts...despite playing in 57 fewer games. On a strictly game-to-game basis, Lindor was therefore the best of MLB's all-time class of young shortstops.
For Lindor personally, the "frustrating" part about his rookie breakthrough is that it didn't lead to a postseason berth for the Indians. But it's certainly fair to say he surpassed expectations, particularly with what he did on offense.
Had you read virtually any scouting report on Lindor ahead of his major league debut on June 14, you would have gotten the gist that his glove was great, but that his bat was probably only good. The reality that he hit only .279 in five minor league seasons seemed to confirm that.
But in hitting .313 with 12 home runs and an .835 OPS in the majors, the switch-hitting Lindor teased that his bat is going to be better than merely good. And for that, he credits the surroundings he walked into.
"That came from the people surrounding me," said Lindor of his eye-opening offensive performance. "Michael Brantley. Jason Kipnis. Carlos Santana. They backed me up a lot. That helped me get the pitches that [I could drive]. There was also the work. The coaching staff makes you put in the work, day in and day out. That helped me as well."
Looking ahead to 2016, Lindor says he wants to continue to improve on his offensive game. But between now and then, he stands to collect a major award in November.
Where it was once deemed as Correa's to lose, now there's quite a bit of support for Lindor to come away with the AL Rookie of the Year award this winter. Among those who favor Lindor are CBS Sports' Jon Heyman, Fox Sports' Ken Rosenthal and Grantland's Jonah Keri.
As for the man himself, Lindor isn't about to toot his own horn. As he sees it, he's a winner either way.
"I think it would be one of the greatest achievements I could achieve in my career," Lindor said of the Rookie of the Year award. "If I do have the blessing to win it, I will be one happy guy. But even if I don't win it, even to be in the race is still a blessing. So I'll be happy [either way]. I just want to continue to play the game the right way, to respect the game, and I'm looking forward to doing so for many years to come."
One thing that should only help Lindor grow as a player, of course, is the reality that it's going to take some hard work to stand out among his fellow young shortstops.
It's not just Correa and Seager that Lindor is going to be measured against. Russell, a fellow 21-year-old, has ability way beyond what his modest 2015 numbers indicate. The 23-year-old Bogaerts is still very much a young shortstop phenom. The Seattle Mariners have a good one in 22-year-old Ketel Marte. Elsewhere, the likes of Andrelton Simmons, Didi Gregorius and Jose Iglesias are only in their mid-20s.
With so much young talent at the shortstop position, debates about the best shortstops in the league are due to get much more heated. Bring it on, says Lindor.
"I want them to be great," he said of his fellow young shortstops. "It's only going to make me a better player. I look forward to the years to come when I think the better they get, the better I'm going to be. ... Hopefully they wish the best to each other, because I wish the best for all of them."
Provided you get a proper kick out of good shortstop talent, this is a heck of a time to be alive. A couple of years ago, MLB was starving for talented young shortstops. Now the league has more of them than it's possibly ever had, and the future may consist of Lindor, Correa, Seager and all the rest trying to outdo one another.
There has been an awakening, all right. And from the looks of things, it should last a while.
Stats courtesy of Baseball-Reference.com and FanGraphs unless otherwise noted/linked. Quotes obtained firsthand unless otherwise noted.
If you want to talk baseball, hit me up on Twitter.
Read more MLB news on BleacherReport.com
- Login to post comments